Tag Archive for: CHIRLA

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers; alberto@uclavrp.org

WIN: CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project Secure Preliminary Injunction Blocking Federal Demands to Set Aside California Ballots

In CHIRLA v. DHS, court finds federal demands likely unconstitutional and recognizes threats to eligible citizens’ voting rights.

WASHINGTON (November 2, 2026) — A federal judge today granted a preliminary injunction blocking the federal government from demanding that California election officials segregate ballots or depart from existing state election procedures based on lists of suspected noncitizens. The ruling comes in a lawsuit brought by the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA) and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by attorneys from CHIRLA and the UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP), including VRP Senior Advisor and Voting Rights Counsel Xavier Becerra.

Chief Judge James E. Boasberg of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia found that the federal government’s demands likely violate the Constitution’s Elections Clause because the Executive Branch lacks authority to unilaterally impose its preferred procedures for verifying citizenship and counting ballots. He also found that CHIRLA had identified citizen members wrongly included on the government’s lists and that election officials’ ongoing review of those lists created a concrete risk to their ability to vote.

“Defendants’ flawed lists risk chilling or preventing lawful votes from being cast and counted …  The disruptive effects of Defendants’ demands, moreover, threaten to extend beyond however many California voters are wrongfully included on the lists. They also threaten to modify the “operation of voter identification procedures” with voting already underway, causing “voter confusion and consequent incentive to remain away from the polls.” Boasberg wrote in his opinion.

“Eligible citizens should not have to fear that their ballots will be set aside because their government wrongly labeled them noncitizens,” said VRP Legal Director Chad Dunn. “Today’s order protects voters from federal demands to change California’s election rules while voting is already underway. We are grateful that the court recognized the harm to CHIRLA and its members. Eligible California voters should go out and vote with confidence, knowing the court has put protections in place against these unlawful demands.”

“The court has seen the evidence and found that both our organization and our members are being harmed by this unconstitutional attack on the right to vote. With Election Day tomorrow, this will give the needed breathing room to our citizen members and all other Californians who wish to vote, our volunteers and staff who engage in electoral work as well as to California officials who work so tirelessly to administer elections and protect the franchise,” said Angelica Salas, Executive Director, of CHIRLA.

Background

The ruling follows an October 30 order requiring the government to provide the disputed list to plaintiffs’ legal team. An analysis by UCLA researchers Matt Barreto and Michael Rios identified at least 22 full matches and 66 additional near-certain matches between the government’s list and CHIRLA’s citizen member and client records. In its opinion, the court described Barreto as “well qualified and credible” and relied on the matching evidence in finding that CHIRLA had established standing to seek relief.

The court also recognized harm to CHIRLA’s work, finding that the organization had redirected limited resources to address voters’ fears and help members protect their voting rights. It concluded that CHIRLA’s members need not wait until their ballots are segregated to seek protection.

The lawsuit, filed September 2, challenges federal actions that plaintiffs argue wrongly target naturalized citizens and interfere with California’s elections. Plaintiffs sought emergency relief after DOJ demanded that election officials withhold or segregate ballots associated with its lists and threatened legal consequences for noncompliance.

The court granted the emergency motion in part, issuing a targeted preliminary injunction against those demands rather than the broader relief requested. The underlying lawsuit continues. DOJ’s separate motion to strike portions of the expert report and seek sanctions remains pending; today’s opinion did not resolve it.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
UCLA VRP: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

Federal Court Sets October 30 Hearing in CHIRLA and Trujillo v. DHS, a Challenge to Federal Actions Targeting California Voters

WASHINGTON (October 21, 2026) — A federal judge today scheduled an October 30 hearing on a request for emergency relief in a lawsuit brought by the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA) and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by the CHIRLA, UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP), and VRP’s Senior Advisor Xaiver Becerra, challenging federal actions targeting California voters identified as alleged noncitizens.

Chief Judge James E. Boasberg of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ordered the plaintiffs to file a superseding motion for a temporary restraining order by October 22. The government’s opposition is due October 26, followed by the plaintiffs’ reply on October 28.

The hearing is scheduled for Friday, October 30, at 10:30 a.m. ET / 7:30 a.m. PT and the counsels will be appearing in person.

The UCLA VRP plaintiffs have sought to stop federal demands and threats aimed at requiring California election officials to remove registered voters, withhold ballots, or segregate and ultimately not count ballots based on federal lists of alleged noncitizens. The superseding motion will set out the request the court will consider under the new schedule.

In a supplemental brief filed today, the plaintiffs described recent federal actions, including the DOJ’s separate lawsuit against California, threats of criminal prosecution against election officials, and Monday’s announcement of criminal charges against 28 lawful permanent residents.

The brief also raises concerns about the accuracy of the federal voter list, citing a senior DOJ official’s acknowledgment that some people listed may ultimately be citizens and reporting that some appear to have been born in the United States.

“Individual allegations must be evaluated on their evidence and through due process,” said Chad Dunn, legal director of the UCLA Voting Rights Project. “They do not justify treating thousands of registered voters as ineligible. We are asking the court to protect eligible voters from being wrongly targeted while voting is already underway.”

The lawsuit, filed September 2, challenges federal database-matching efforts and demands that state election officials act on the resulting lists. The plaintiffs argue that these actions exceed federal authority and violate constitutional protections and federal law.

Today’s order sets a briefing schedule and hearing. The court has not granted or denied the requested temporary restraining order.

“The events of the last few days, from threats to state and local officials, increased general immigration operations, the random knocking on doors by federal agents and the recent arrests are causing a chill in the community. People, including naturalized citizens, are making their plans to vote and the Federal Government is doing its utmost to quash their attempts to exercise this fundamental right that they have lawfully acquired. We look forward to bringing all this to the court’s attention next week,” stated Carl Bergquist, General Counsel, Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA).

Background

The lawsuit, filed September 2 by CHIRLA and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by the CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project attorney, challenges federal database-matching efforts that plaintiffs argue risk wrongly identifying naturalized citizens as noncitizens and interfering with California’s elections. 

The dispute escalated last week after the DOJ gave California officials 48 hours to review a list of more than 20,000 alleged noncitizen registrants and demanded that officials withhold or segregate ballots from people whose citizenship they could not independently confirm. 

On October 15, the plaintiffs filed an emergency application for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. That same day, DOJ filed a separate lawsuit against California, Secretary of State Shirley Weber, and Los Angeles County elections chief Dean Logan seeking to prevent ballots from listed voters from being counted until their citizenship was verified. Federal officials subsequently warned of potential criminal consequences for election officials who knowingly processed ballots from noncitizens. The plaintiffs argue that these demands threaten eligible voters and violate federal authority limits and restrictions on systematic voter removals within 90 days of an election.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.