FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
UCLA VRP: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

Native Voters Challenge Unequal Voting Districts in Blaine County, Montana

Represented by the UCLA Voting Rights Project and Upper Seven Law, the plaintiffs seek a new county commission map, alleging diminished Native American voting strength.

Billings, Mont. (November 5, 2026) — On Wednesday, three voters challenged the County Commissioner district map for Blaine County for violating the U.S. Constitution’s one-person, one-vote rule. The one-person, one-vote rule requires that when voters elect officials to represent them in districted bodies like county commissions, the districts must be roughly equal in population. This ensures that every person’s vote weighs the same, regardless of where they live. Blaine County’s map distributes population unequally between three districts, diluting the votes of Native American Montanans. The UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP) and Helena-based Upper Seven Law represent plaintiffs. The suit was filed in federal district court.

In Blaine County, voters elect three commissioners from separate districts. The complaint alleges that under the existing district map, the population variation between districts exceeds constitutional limits. The County’s most populous district, District 1, is predominantly Native American and contains nearly 700 more residents than the County’s smallest district. Districts with more voters must distribute the power to elect an official across more people, which dilutes the relative power of residents in the more populous district compared to the smaller, less populous district. In Blaine County, this means that it takes approximately 1.32 people voting in District 1, the most populous district, to have the same effect as 1 person voting in District 2, the least populous district.

According to the complaint, the county’s own figures show that District 1, whose population is 94.9% American Indian, is overpopulated by 16%, while the predominantly white District 2 is underpopulated by 12%. The complaint alleges that these population disparities violate equal protection under the Fourteenth Amendment’s well-settled one person, one vote rule. 

“The weight of a person’s vote should not depend on which side of a district line they live on,” said Sonni Waknin, senior voting rights counsel at the VRP. “Blaine County’s map goes against the principles of our representative government. We are asking the Court to enforce the Constitution and require districts that give voters an equal voice in their county government.”

Blaine County adopted a district-based county commissioner map in 2002, after a federal court found that the at-large system used previously diluted American Indian votes. In the years since, county officials have interpreted that earlier ruling to require  them to preserve the districts’ racial composition. Plaintiffs say this interpretation is wrong and that the County’s  2024 plan retains boundaries established in 2013 despite uneven population changes, worsening existing disparities.

“The right to vote is the starting premise of our free society–it ensures that we, the people, can hold our government accountable to the rule of law,” said Molly Danahy, litigation director at Upper Seven Law. “Districts that violate the basic principle that every vote should count the same are unconstitutional. Blaine County’s Commissioner map must distribute power equally among its voters.”

Plaintiffs ask the court to declare the current map unconstitutional, prohibit its use in 2028 and any future elections, and require Blaine County to implement a plan that equalizes district populations. Defendants include Blaine County, its county commissioners, and county election officials.

Read the filing here.

About the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

About Upper Seven Law

Upper Seven Law is a Montana-based nonprofit law firm dedicated to holding the powerful accountable. 

 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers; alberto@uclavrp.org

WIN: CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project Secure Preliminary Injunction Blocking Federal Demands to Set Aside California Ballots

In CHIRLA v. DHS, court finds federal demands likely unconstitutional and recognizes threats to eligible citizens’ voting rights.

WASHINGTON (November 2, 2026) — A federal judge today granted a preliminary injunction blocking the federal government from demanding that California election officials segregate ballots or depart from existing state election procedures based on lists of suspected noncitizens. The ruling comes in a lawsuit brought by the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA) and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by attorneys from CHIRLA and the UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP), including VRP Senior Advisor and Voting Rights Counsel Xavier Becerra.

Chief Judge James E. Boasberg of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia found that the federal government’s demands likely violate the Constitution’s Elections Clause because the Executive Branch lacks authority to unilaterally impose its preferred procedures for verifying citizenship and counting ballots. He also found that CHIRLA had identified citizen members wrongly included on the government’s lists and that election officials’ ongoing review of those lists created a concrete risk to their ability to vote.

“Defendants’ flawed lists risk chilling or preventing lawful votes from being cast and counted …  The disruptive effects of Defendants’ demands, moreover, threaten to extend beyond however many California voters are wrongfully included on the lists. They also threaten to modify the “operation of voter identification procedures” with voting already underway, causing “voter confusion and consequent incentive to remain away from the polls.” Boasberg wrote in his opinion.

“Eligible citizens should not have to fear that their ballots will be set aside because their government wrongly labeled them noncitizens,” said VRP Legal Director Chad Dunn. “Today’s order protects voters from federal demands to change California’s election rules while voting is already underway. We are grateful that the court recognized the harm to CHIRLA and its members. Eligible California voters should go out and vote with confidence, knowing the court has put protections in place against these unlawful demands.”

“The court has seen the evidence and found that both our organization and our members are being harmed by this unconstitutional attack on the right to vote. With Election Day tomorrow, this will give the needed breathing room to our citizen members and all other Californians who wish to vote, our volunteers and staff who engage in electoral work as well as to California officials who work so tirelessly to administer elections and protect the franchise,” said Angelica Salas, Executive Director, of CHIRLA.

Background

The ruling follows an October 30 order requiring the government to provide the disputed list to plaintiffs’ legal team. An analysis by UCLA researchers Matt Barreto and Michael Rios identified at least 22 full matches and 66 additional near-certain matches between the government’s list and CHIRLA’s citizen member and client records. In its opinion, the court described Barreto as “well qualified and credible” and relied on the matching evidence in finding that CHIRLA had established standing to seek relief.

The court also recognized harm to CHIRLA’s work, finding that the organization had redirected limited resources to address voters’ fears and help members protect their voting rights. It concluded that CHIRLA’s members need not wait until their ballots are segregated to seek protection.

The lawsuit, filed September 2, challenges federal actions that plaintiffs argue wrongly target naturalized citizens and interfere with California’s elections. Plaintiffs sought emergency relief after DOJ demanded that election officials withhold or segregate ballots associated with its lists and threatened legal consequences for noncompliance.

The court granted the emergency motion in part, issuing a targeted preliminary injunction against those demands rather than the broader relief requested. The underlying lawsuit continues. DOJ’s separate motion to strike portions of the expert report and seek sanctions remains pending; today’s opinion did not resolve it.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers; alberto@uclavrp.org

WIN: Federal Judge Orders DOJ to Turn Over List of More Than 20,000 Alleged Noncitizen Voters to CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project Legal Teams

In a significant victory in CHIRLA v. DHS, judge orders disclosure by 5 p.m. ET, allowing plaintiffs’ attorneys to examine the list and protect eligible voters.

WASHINGTON (October 30, 2026) — Chief Judge James E. Boasberg today ordered the U.S. Department of Justice to provide the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA) and the UCLA Voting Rights Project legal teams (VRP) with its list of more than 20,000 California registrants identified as alleged noncitizens by 5 p.m. ET. The order followed a hearing in the lawsuit brought by CHIRLA and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by attorneys from CHIRLA and the UCLA Voting Rights Project, including VRP Senior Advisor Xavier Becerra.

Access to the list will allow the plaintiffs’ legal teams to examine whom the government has identified and assess its impact on eligible voters. Plaintiffs argue that federal database-matching efforts risk wrongly flagging naturalized citizens and that demands to withhold or segregate ballots intimidate voters and interfere with election administration.

“We’re grateful for the court’s ruling, which gives us an opportunity to examine the government’s list and protect our clients’ right to vote,” said VRP Legal Director Chad Dunn. “Citizens should not have to file a lawsuit to find out whether their own government has wrongly labeled them noncitizens on a secret list.”

“The court’s ruling allows us to inspect these flawed lists to protect our CHIRLA members and clients who may be flagged incorrectly as noncitizen voters. Moreover, we will continue to seek broad relief against the Government’s attempt to intimidate voters, local and state officials alike during what should be a ‘quiet’ as we engage in the solemn work of exercising the right to vote and participate in fair and free elections,” added CHIRLA General Counsel Carl Bergquist.

Plaintiffs argue that the government’s actions are already causing harm by making eligible citizens, including naturalized citizens, afraid to vote. The government’s continued demands and threats of prosecution against election officials compound that fear, while voters have no way to know whether they have been wrongly included on its list. CHIRLA has had to devote additional time and resources to addressing those concerns and helping eligible voters understand and exercise their rights.

The court called for supplemental briefing on standing following disclosure of the list. 

Earlier this week, a federal judge in United States v. California denied a Department of Justice’s request to require California to set aside ballots. The CHIRLA case seeks an affirmative order against the broader federal policy plaintiffs challenge.

Background

The lawsuit, filed September 2 by CHIRLA and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by attorneys from CHIRLA and the UCLA Voting Rights Project, challenges federal database-matching efforts that plaintiffs argue risk wrongly identifying naturalized citizens as noncitizens and interfering with California’s elections.

On October 15, plaintiffs sought a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction after DOJ gave California officials 48 hours to review a list of more than 20,000 alleged noncitizen registrants and demanded that officials withhold or segregate ballots from people whose citizenship they could not independently confirm. Plaintiffs argue that those demands and subsequent threats of criminal consequences for election officials exceed federal authority and threaten eligible citizens’ right to vote.

Following the case’s reassignment to Chief Judge James E. Boasberg, the court held a scheduling conference on October 21. Plaintiffs filed a superseding emergency motion on October 22, incorporating subsequent federal actions and additional evidence of harm to naturalized citizens and CHIRLA’s voter assistance work. The motion asks the court to halt the challenged policy, including efforts to pressure election officials to remove registered voters, withhold their ballots or refuse to count their votes.

The government filed its opposition on October 26, and plaintiffs filed their reply on October 28, completing briefing ahead of the October 30 hearing.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
UCLA VRP: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

Federal Court Sets October 30 Hearing in CHIRLA and Trujillo v. DHS, a Challenge to Federal Actions Targeting California Voters

WASHINGTON (October 21, 2026) — A federal judge today scheduled an October 30 hearing on a request for emergency relief in a lawsuit brought by the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA) and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by the CHIRLA, UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP), and VRP’s Senior Advisor Xaiver Becerra, challenging federal actions targeting California voters identified as alleged noncitizens.

Chief Judge James E. Boasberg of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ordered the plaintiffs to file a superseding motion for a temporary restraining order by October 22. The government’s opposition is due October 26, followed by the plaintiffs’ reply on October 28.

The hearing is scheduled for Friday, October 30, at 10:30 a.m. ET / 7:30 a.m. PT and the counsels will be appearing in person.

The UCLA VRP plaintiffs have sought to stop federal demands and threats aimed at requiring California election officials to remove registered voters, withhold ballots, or segregate and ultimately not count ballots based on federal lists of alleged noncitizens. The superseding motion will set out the request the court will consider under the new schedule.

In a supplemental brief filed today, the plaintiffs described recent federal actions, including the DOJ’s separate lawsuit against California, threats of criminal prosecution against election officials, and Monday’s announcement of criminal charges against 28 lawful permanent residents.

The brief also raises concerns about the accuracy of the federal voter list, citing a senior DOJ official’s acknowledgment that some people listed may ultimately be citizens and reporting that some appear to have been born in the United States.

“Individual allegations must be evaluated on their evidence and through due process,” said Chad Dunn, legal director of the UCLA Voting Rights Project. “They do not justify treating thousands of registered voters as ineligible. We are asking the court to protect eligible voters from being wrongly targeted while voting is already underway.”

The lawsuit, filed September 2, challenges federal database-matching efforts and demands that state election officials act on the resulting lists. The plaintiffs argue that these actions exceed federal authority and violate constitutional protections and federal law.

Today’s order sets a briefing schedule and hearing. The court has not granted or denied the requested temporary restraining order.

“The events of the last few days, from threats to state and local officials, increased general immigration operations, the random knocking on doors by federal agents and the recent arrests are causing a chill in the community. People, including naturalized citizens, are making their plans to vote and the Federal Government is doing its utmost to quash their attempts to exercise this fundamental right that they have lawfully acquired. We look forward to bringing all this to the court’s attention next week,” stated Carl Bergquist, General Counsel, Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA).

Background

The lawsuit, filed September 2 by CHIRLA and California voter Pedro Trujillo, represented by the CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project attorney, challenges federal database-matching efforts that plaintiffs argue risk wrongly identifying naturalized citizens as noncitizens and interfering with California’s elections. 

The dispute escalated last week after the DOJ gave California officials 48 hours to review a list of more than 20,000 alleged noncitizen registrants and demanded that officials withhold or segregate ballots from people whose citizenship they could not independently confirm. 

On October 15, the plaintiffs filed an emergency application for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. That same day, DOJ filed a separate lawsuit against California, Secretary of State Shirley Weber, and Los Angeles County elections chief Dean Logan seeking to prevent ballots from listed voters from being counted until their citizenship was verified. Federal officials subsequently warned of potential criminal consequences for election officials who knowingly processed ballots from noncitizens. The plaintiffs argue that these demands threaten eligible voters and violate federal authority limits and restrictions on systematic voter removals within 90 days of an election.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project Ask Court to Stop Justice Department from Targeting California Voters

With voting already underway, the emergency motion challenges a federal demand targeting voters identified as alleged noncitizens less than three weeks before Election Day

LOS ANGELES (October 15, 2026) — Attorneys with the UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP), including Senior Advisor Xavier Becerra, and the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA), representing CHIRLA and California voter Pedro Trujillo, today filed an emergency application for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction asking a federal court to stop the Department of Justice from using a list of alleged noncitizens to withhold or segregate California voters’ ballots.

Immediately following the filing this morning, the court directed the parties to confer and submit a joint status report by October 16 proposing a briefing schedule and addressing whether a hearing is necessary. The emergency motion remains pending.

The emergency motion follows an October 13 letter in which the Justice Department gave California officials 48 hours to review the federal list or face legal action. According to the motion, federal officials provided the state officials with a thumb drive containing the names of people they believe are noncitizens who received mail ballots. DOJ directed election officials to withhold ballots from those on the list or segregate returned ballots and not count them.

The plaintiffs are asking the court to prevent the federal government from using the list while the lawsuit moves forward. If the court does not grant that request, they are asking for protections that would allow affected voters to learn whether they have been included and provide documentation confirming their citizenship before their ballots are excluded.

“The federal government does not have the constitutional authority to take control of California’s elections or dictate which ballots state and local officials should count,” said Chad Dunn, legal director of the VRP. “With voting already underway, eligible citizens should not have their ballots withheld based on a federal list they have never seen and have had no opportunity to challenge. We are asking the court to intervene before voters suffer harm that cannot be corrected after Election Day.”

“As citizens, including many naturalized CHIRLA members, are preparing to solemnly exercise their constitutional right to cast a vote in the ongoing elections, the Federal Government is threatening at this late hour to extinguish their opportunity to do so,” said Carl Bergquist, CHIRLA General Counsel. ”The letter sent to California election officials necessitated our move to shield these rights, and to prevent the mass disenfranchisement of lawful citizens, some of whom are exercising this right for the very first time.”

The motion argues that the federal government’s demand exceeds the authority granted to the Executive Branch and would force California election officials to violate the National Voter Registration Act, which prohibits systematic voter-removal programs during the 90 days before a federal election.

The plaintiffs have requested immediate relief because California officials were directed to respond to the Justice Department by noon Eastern on October 15. The court may rule on the written filings, request a response from the federal government or schedule a hearing.

Read the emergency motion here and the court order here.

###

Background

CHIRLA filed the lawsuit on September 2, 2026, challenging the federal government’s use of databases—including the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements system—to identify registered voters as alleged noncitizens and pressure states to alter their voter rolls. The lawsuit alleges that the process inaccurately targets naturalized citizens, infringes voters’ constitutional and privacy rights, and unlawfully interferes with state election administration.

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project Notify Justice Department of Planned Emergency Motion to Protect California Voters

LOS ANGELES (October 14, 2026) — Today, UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP) attorneys, including Senior Advisor Xavier Becerra, representing the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA) and California voter Pedro Trujillo notified the U.S. Department of Justice that they will seek emergency court relief over the federal government’s use of federal databases to identify registered California voters as alleged noncitizens.

According to the letter, the Justice Department recently gave California officials, including officials in Los Angeles County, 48 hours to remove or segregate voters identified through the federal government’s review. The VRP plaintiffs contend that the government’s use of these lists is unlawful and could result in eligible citizens being wrongly targeted less than a month before the election. Furthermore, the Justice Department’s demands would force California election officials to violate the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA), which prevents the purging of voters from voter rolls 90-days prior to a federal election. 

“The federal government should not be pressuring California election officials to act on an unreliable list, at all. Regardless, voters should have a meaningful opportunity to learn whether they have been targeted by federal officials and an opportunity to correct inaccurate information before their Right to Vote is disturbed,” said Chad Dunn, legal director of the VRP. “We are seeking immediate court ordered safeguards to prevent eligible citizens from being wrongly removed or segregated in the final weeks before the election.”

“The federal government’s attempt to pressure California election officials into acting on lists that may misidentify eligible voters is an alarming abuse of power as election season gets underway.  This puts our communities and our fundamental rights at risk. Citizenship is citizenship. Period. The federal government must stop undermining federal and state law, sowing fear, and attempting to silence voters. CHIRLA and UCLA Voting Rights Project will uplift every eligible Californian’s right to vote and ensure that our democracy remains a place where every voice counts,” said Carl Bergquist, CHIRLA General Counsel. 

The letter invites the Justice Department attorneys to meet and confer on the request before it is filed and expect a response by then. Plaintiffs will ask the Court to prevent the federal government from using the voter lists while the lawsuit moves forward. If that request is not granted, they will ask for protections allowing California voters to find out whether they are on a federal list and confirm their citizenship.

Read the letter here.

Background

CHIRLA and Trujillo filed the lawsuit on September 2, 2026, challenging the federal government’s use of databases—including the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements system—to identify registered voters as alleged noncitizens and pressure states to alter their voter rolls. The lawsuit alleges that the process inaccurately targets naturalized citizens, infringes voters’ constitutional and privacy rights, and unlawfully interferes with state election administration.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

U.S. Supreme Court Sends Washington State Legislative Map Case Back to Court of Appeals

WASHINGTON (October 5, 2026) — Today, the U.S. Supreme Court, in a procedural move, sent Trevino v. Hobbs back to the lower court for further review based on the April 2026 decision in Louisiana v. Callais. On behalf of Latino voters in Washington state’s Yakima Valley, Campaign Legal Center, the UCLA Voting Rights Project, the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF), and Morfin Law Firm, PLLC will continue to defend the rights of all Washingtonians to have an equal say in electing state legislators who best serve their community.

Following a decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit that affirmed the legality of a new Washington state legislative map put in place by a district court to remedy a violation of Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA), two voters who had intervened in the litigation brought this case to the Supreme Court, continuing an effort to resist a fair map for Washington’s voters. On October 5, 2026, after considering the intervenors’ petition to review the case, the Supreme Court granted intervenors’ petition, vacated the previous decision and sent the case back for further review in the Ninth Circuit in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling in Louisiana v. Callais earlier this year.

“We won this case twice already, and we intend to win again. As a result of our previous litigation, Latino voters in Yakima Valley had an equal voice in state legislative elections for the first time in decades,” said Annabelle Harless, director of redistricting at Campaign Legal Center. “Despite recent Supreme Court actions weakening the Voting Rights Act, we will continue to fight for fair maps to ensure that Latino voters in Washington State’s Yakima Valley have a fair chance to elect state legislators who best serve their community.”

“The 2021 Washington state Legislative redistricting denied Yakima and Tri-Cities Latinos the chance at equal representation, but our lawsuit remedied that in 2023,” said Ernest Herrera, MALDEF Western Regional Counsel. “Today’s Supreme Court’s orders do not change the fact that the Voting Rights Act guarantees Latinos equal opportunity to elect candidates who represent them in Washington’s state Legislature, and we will fight to keep a fair map in the Ninth Circuit.”

“Today’s order does not decide the merits of this case,” said Sonni Waknin, senior voting rights counsel at the UCLA Voting Rights Project. “We will continue to move forward and ensure that a fair map exists in Washington state.”

“I think that the lower courts got it right on the law. I sometimes dream of a perfect world, where we have fair and equal representation, and ethical governance, where elected representatives care about the needs of the entire population,” said Edwardo Morfin of Morfin Law Firm, PLLC. “But, since we do not live in a perfect world, we need to wake up and keep fighting to get closer to that dream.”

Background:

In January 2022, Campaign Legal Center (CLC), alongside co-counsel MALDEF (Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund), the UCLA Voting Rights Project, and attorney Edwardo Morfin of the Morfin Law Firm in Washington, sued on behalf of individual Latino voters in the Yakima Valley region, arguing that Washington’s state Legislative District 15 violated Section 2 of the VRA.

A federal judge ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, agreeing that the map violated Section 2 because the challenged district diluted the voting strength of Latino voters. Following this violation, a remedial map, which was drawn without any consideration of race, was implemented to allow voters in the Yakima Valley region an equal opportunity to participate in the political process.

Following the lower court’s decisions, intervenors appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in an attempt to get the fair map overturned.

The Ninth Circuit found that the intervenors lacked standing to challenge the district court’s liability ruling and affirmed that the new remedial district put in place to address the Section 2 VRA violation complies with federal law.

Following plaintiffs’ win at the Ninth Circuit, intervenors filed a petition for a writ of certiorari at the Supreme Court, seeking to overturn the Ninth Circuit’s decision.

More information about our case is available here.

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers, alberto@uclavrp.org

California Supreme Court Orders Return of More Than 650,000 Riverside County Ballots Seized by Sheriff Chad Bianco

The decision in Cervantes v. Bianco addresses the custody and handling of voted ballots under California law.

LOS ANGELES (September 24, 2026) – Today, the California Supreme Court ruled in favor of four Riverside County voters represented by the UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP) and Senior Voting Rights Advisor Xavier Becerra, finding that Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco unlawfully seized more than 650,000 voted ballots and ordering him to return them to the Riverside County Registrar of Voters.

In Cervantes et al. v. Bianco, VRP challenged Bianco’s seizure and handling of ballots cast in the November 2025 special election. The petitioners argued that California election law establishes specific requirements governing the custody, inspection, and handling of voted ballots and that a criminal search warrant does not allow law enforcement to bypass those safeguards and count cast ballots outside of public scrutiny.

In its decision, the Court held that the seizure was unlawful because California law requires voted ballots to remain in custody of election officials, even during a criminal investigation. The Court found that a search warrant does not override those protections and ordered Bianco to return the ballots to the Registrar and stop handling them except as necessary to comply with the order.

“The Court’s decision reaffirms a basic principle that in California, the Election Code applies to everyone, including law enforcement,” said Chad Dunn, Legal Director of the VRP. “These are the voters’ ballots. They must be protected through the processes the Legislature has established. This ruling provides important clarity for election officials, law enforcement, and voters across California.”

“The High Court for the state of California has spoken,” said Riverside City Councilmember Clarissa Cervantes, who is a plaintiff in the case. “The rule of law has been upheld, and your sacred ballot and vote are constitutionally protected from any outside political interference. Thank you to our attorneys at UCLA Voting Rights Project, Xavier Becerra, and Attorney General Rob Bonta for their outstanding legal and distinguished representation.”

“Voters need to know their privacy is protected, their ballot is safe and secure, our elections are fair, and election laws must be followed by everyone,” said Becki Robinson, a plaintiff in the case.

“We thank the Court for affirming that the Sheriff has no role in the ballot chain of custody under the Elections Code. We call on California voters to reject similar attacks on voting rights this November,” said Nathan P. Kempe, a plaintiff and the operations director at Starting Over Strong,

Plaintiff and Indio City Councilmember Oscar Ortiz added, “My hope is that this ruling will protect not only the voting process of Riverside County, but also set the precedent for other counties and other states around the country. This ruling demonstrates to our American communities how we can use the legal tools provided by our federal and state constitutions to stop those who wish to manipulate our voting processes for their own political advantage.”

“Today the California Supreme Court handed voters a great victory when it rejected Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco’s attempt to use his badge to illegally seize thousands of cast ballots,” said Xavier Becerra, senior voting rights advisor to the VRP, former California Attorney General, and an attorney of record in the case. “The Court knocked election deniers off their feet and strengthened our hand in election protection just ahead of the November vote. We must use every lever at our disposal to beat back voter interference and intimidation. Californians’ faith and confidence in our elections depend on it.”

“Today’s ruling has made it clear that a criminal investigation is not a blanket license to ignore California election law,” said Sonni Waknin, Senior Voting Rights Counsel at the VRP. “The Court has affirmed that when questions arise about an election, there are lawful and transparent procedures that must be followed. Those safeguards are essential to protecting voted ballots and maintaining public confidence in our elections.”

Read the opinion here.

Background

The UCLA Voting Rights Project filed an original petition with the California Supreme Court on March 25 on behalf of Riverside County voters Clarissa Cervantes, Oscar Ortiz, Rebecca Robinson, and Nathan Kempe after Bianco seized voted ballots and other election materials from the Riverside County Registrar of Voters as part of an investigation into alleged discrepancies in the November 2025 election.

The petitioners argued that California election law establishes specific safeguards governing the custody, inspection, counting, and preservation of voted ballots and that a criminal search warrant does not allow law enforcement to bypass those requirements.

As the case proceeded, VRP continued to raise concerns with the Court about the seizure and handling of the election materials. The California Supreme Court ultimately ordered the parties to address whether the voters are entitled to have the cast ballots returned to the Registrar on the grounds that their seizure pursuant to search warrants violated the Elections Code.

In their June 29 filing, the petitioners asked the Court to return the ballots and election materials to the Registrar, require an accounting of their handling while outside election officials’ custody, and disclose whether any ballot seals, tapes, ballots or records had been damaged, destroyed or altered.

On August 24, the Court also heard arguments in the related matter Attorney General of the State of California v. Bianco, S295901. That case raises a separate question involving the Attorney General’s authority over local law enforcement. The two matters arise from the same Riverside County ballot seizure but present distinct legal issues.

###

ABOUT the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers; alammers@luskin.ucla.edu

UCLA Study Finds Disparities in Mail Ballot Rejections and Evidence That Racial Cues May Influence Signature Reviews

Analysis of California and Washington state election data underscores the need for further research and stronger safeguards for eligible voters.

LOS ANGELES (September 14, 2026) — Young and non-White voters are substantially more likely to have their vote-by-mail ballots rejected, while experimental evidence suggests racial cues may influence the subjective decisions involved in signature verification, according to a new research brief from the UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP).

More than 580,000 vote-by-mail ballots were rejected nationwide during the 2024 general election. Signature discrepancies were the leading reason for rejection, accounting for 59% of rejected ballots in California and 64% in Washington state.

The brief authored by Michael Herndon, a senior research fellow at the VRP, finds that the subjective process of signature verification disproportionately penalizes non-White voters and young voters in both states. In an analysis of Washington state election data, Hispanic-surnamed voters were approximately twice as likely as White voters to have their ballots rejected because of a signature mismatch. In some counties this disparity was even larger. For example, in Adams County, Hispanic voters experienced a rejection rate more than four times that of White voters between 2019 and 2024.

The research also found:

  • Young voters faced substantially higher rejection rates. Across every racial group examined in California’s 2022 general election, voters younger than 25 were considerably more likely to have their signatures rejected than voters older than 65. In Riverside County, Latino voters younger than 25 were 15 times more likely to experience a signature rejection.
  • Racial cues influenced signature-matching decisions in controlled experiments. In one experiment, participants accepted signatures assigned White-sounding names at a rate of 60.5%, compared with 55% for signatures assigned Hispanic-sounding names—even though the names were randomly assigned and the underlying signatures were comparable.

The experiments did not examine actual election workers, but the findings raise questions about whether personal biases can affect VBM ballot verification, especially considering that the process varies by county, is done under time constraints, and happens at a massive scale. 

“A signature isn’t just a mark on a page; it also carries with it a name, which can very easily signal a person’s gender, race, religion or other personal characteristics,” said Herndon. “Decades of research tell us that people respond to these name-based cues, and they do it most when a task is ambiguous and left to their own judgment—which is exactly the case for signature verification.”

Herndon argues that the growing use of vote-by-mail makes closer examination of signature verification increasingly important. Because voters are not physically present when their ballots are reviewed, local election officials typically verify their identity by comparing the signature on the ballot envelope with signatures in the voter’s registration record. Voters whose ballots are flagged for missing or mismatched signatures must complete a curing process before their ballots can be counted, though not all states offer this remedy

The brief recommends evaluating differences in signature-review procedures and rejection rates across counties, broadening recruitment for the elections workforce, expanding automatic ballot curing and reassessing whether signature matching should remain the default method for verifying mail ballots. It also calls for further research into which technologies, training practices and administrative workflows make ballot review more accurate and less susceptible to bias.

Read the full brief here.

About the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research, and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.

 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Alberto Lammers; alammers@luskin.ucla.edu

Victory for Galveston, TX Voters: Illegal Map Struck Down as Fight Still Continues for Fair Representation

AUSTIN, Texas (September 11, 2026) — Today, in an important step toward fair maps for Galveston voters, the Texas Supreme Court ruled that county commissioners in Galveston County, Texas, unlawfully disenfranchised Galveston’s voters through the 2026 map enacted between the primary and general elections.

Today’s ruling is the result of a petition filed by Campaign Legal Center (CLC) and UCLA Voting Rights Project (VRP) on behalf of Galveston County voters, which argued that the passage of this new map mid-election without any mechanism for voters and candidates to participate equally under the new map violated not only the Texas Constitution, but also the United States Constitution and Texas Election Code.

While this victory is important, the longer fight for fair maps continues in federal court. Galveston County has a long history of drawing maps in a way that discriminates against and diminishes the voting strength of Black and Latino voters, and the map that was in place for the 2026 primary is no exception. The 2021 maps are the subject of ongoing federal litigation in which CLC and VRP argue that they constitute unlawful and intentionally discriminatory racial gerrymandering.

“Although the fight for fair maps in Galveston County is far from over, today’s victory sends a clear sign that Galveston County cannot illegally disenfranchise its voters,” said Mark Gaber, senior director of redistricting at Campaign Legal Center. “Electoral systems that intentionally discriminate against voters in communities of color deprive voters of an equal opportunity to participate in the political process. While we celebrate this victory at the Texas Supreme Court, we are still continuing our fight in Galveston to ensure that any discriminatory maps are struck down so all voters can make their voices heard.” 

“Today’s ruling protects the right of voters and candidates to participate equally in our elections,” said Bernadette Reyes, senior staff attorney at the VRP. “Galveston County cannot change district boundaries in the middle of an election and deny voters and candidates an equal opportunity to participate in a new map.” 

Background:

In October 2023, a federal judge ruled that Galveston County’s redistricting map, which denied Black and Latino voters an equal opportunity to elect a candidate of their choice, violated Section 2 of the federal Voting Rights Act (VRA).

While the map had been struck down by the federal district court judge, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ordered that the illegal map could remain in place for the 2024 election — the same map the federal judge had deemed “mean-spirited” and “egregious” in his October 2023 ruling. This order was later affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Read the ruling here.

About the UCLA Voting Rights Project

The UCLA Voting Rights Project was established to protect equal voting rights for all Americans through strategic litigation, social science research, and policy advocacy. The VRP seeks to ensure that all individuals are afforded equal access to the electoral process and representation in governance. For more information about the UCLA Voting Rights Project, please visit vrp.ucla.edu.